The debate surrounding who is the best batter among the ‘Fab 4’.Joe Root, Virat Kohli, Steve Smith, and Kane Williamson have captivated cricket enthusiasts for years.
Each player has made significant contributions to Test cricket, but Joe Root’s recent performances and statistics position him as a strong contender for this title.
This article delves into Root’s career achievements, comparing them with his peers to assess whether he truly stands out among the Fab 4.
ALSO READ: Analyzing The Captaincy Records Of The Fab Four In International Cricket
A Statistical Snapshot of the Fab 4
To understand Root’s standing, it’s essential to look at the key statistics of the Fab 4 in Test cricket:
- Virat Kohli: 8,848 runs in 113 Tests at an average of 49.15, with 29 centuries and 30 half-centuries.
- Steve Smith: 9,685 runs in 109 Tests at an average of 57.32, with 32 centuries and 41 half-centuries.
- Kane Williamson: 8,743 runs in 100 Tests at an average of 54.89, with 32 centuries and 34 half-centuries.
- Joe Root: 12,402 runs in 146 Tests at an average of 50.62, with 34 centuries and 64 half-centuries.
Root leads in total runs, centuries, and half-centuries. This statistical dominance reflects not only his longevity but also his consistency at the highest level.
The Case for Joe Root
While statistics are significant, several factors further bolster Joe Root’s claim as the best among the Fab 4.
Consistency Across Conditions
Root’s ability to perform in diverse conditions sets him apart. Although he has yet to score a century in Australia, he maintains an impressive average of nearly 40 on their challenging pitches.
His adaptability shines through as he has scored centuries in various countries, excelling on both fast tracks and slow pitches. This versatility demonstrates his capability to thrive regardless of conditions.
Carrying England’s Batting Line-Up
Since Alastair Cook’s retirement in 2018, Root has been the cornerstone of England’s batting lineup. He has often found himself rescuing the team from precarious situations due to a lack of stable partners. This added responsibility highlights his resilience and ability to perform under pressure qualities that are crucial in Test cricket.
Second-Innings Dominance
Root boasts an impressive second-innings average of 59, significantly higher than his peers. His performance during these crucial moments underscores his mental toughness and adaptability. His fourth-innings average of 41 also showcases his skill in difficult chases, where other players may falter.
Impact on Series
A pivotal measure of greatness is a player’s impact on series outcomes. Joe Root has won the most Player of the Series awards among the Fab 4, with nine accolades. This achievement underscores his match-winning capabilities and influence on series results.
Record-Breaking Year: 2021
Root’s performance in 2021 was exceptional; he scored 1,710 runs in just 11 matches, breaking records for the most runs scored in a calendar year. His tally included 7 centuries and 4 half-centuries, showcasing his ability to sustain form against tough opposition.
Most Centuries and Half-Centuries
With 34 centuries and 64 half-centuries, Root holds the record for the most among the Fab 4. While Smith boasts a higher batting average, Root’s consistency in converting starts into significant scores is noteworthy.
Conclusion
Joe Root’s case for being considered the best among the Fab 4 is compelling. His statistical achievements are complemented by his adaptability across conditions, ability to shoulder responsibility during challenging times, and impressive performances under pressure.
While Steve Smith may have a higher batting average and Kohli and Williamson possess their unique strengths, Root’s all-around consistency and match-winning contributions make him a formidable contender for this title.
As cricket fans continue to witness the brilliance of these four players, it is clear that Joe Root stands out as a serious candidate for being recognized as the best batter among them. Each player has left an indelible mark on the game, but if we measure greatness by adaptability and impact, Root’s name resonates strongly within this elite group.
ALSO READ: Joe Root: England’s Greatest Batter Of All Time?